Table 4 shows the brands of certified beef developed by retailers in Spain and Italy
with highlighted product guaranteed attributes.
Table 4.Brands of certified 3 beef developed by retailers in
Spain and Italy
Retailer |
Spain______________________________________________ |
Italy_________________________________________________________________ | ||||||||
Brand________ |
Characteristics____________________ |
Brand____________ |
Characteristics_________________________ | |||||||
Carrefour |
Calidad Tradicion Carrefour |
Pure cattle breeds and cross- 100% vegetable feed; Full traceability from farm to Slaughtered and cut in Spain. |
Filiera Qualità Carrefour |
Full respect of animal welfare for Vegetable feed free from growth Born in France and Italy; Italian slaughterhouses and feed Three French breeds (Limousine, | ||||||
Auchan |
Produccion |
Animals bred in Certicar certified 100% vegetable feed; Packaged between 48 and 96h Reinforced control mechanism Full traceability from farm to |
Filiera Controllata Auchan |
Animals selection; Respect of breeding methods, such as Chain third part certification and Slaughterhouses selection and audit; Control during transport; Good taste .______________________________ | ||||||
Eroski |
Carnspalleja, Kampio______ |
Animals bred in Certicar certified farms; 100% vegetable feed, without use of growth promoter antibiotics; Full traceability from farm to store; Minimum maturation period (varies according to the weight of the carcass). |
Not | |||||||
COOP |
Not |
Qualità Sicura COOP |
Selection of the breeds (Limousine and Charolaise); Controlled feeding (vegetable and OGM free) and fattening; Analyses on animals, farms and meat for anabolic steroids, drug residue, Respect of animal welfare; Selection and strong contracts with slaughtering and cutting; Internal audit._____________________________________________________________________________ | |||||||
Esselunga |
Not present in |
Naturama |
Cattle from Ireland bred extensively: (< 2 grazing heads/ha), intensive All suppliers (often on an exclusive basis) accept these specifications and are | |||||||
Panorama |
Not present in |
Programma Natura |
Selections of breeds (Garonnese and Piedmontese cattle); Full traceability; Breeding information; Nourished with the fodder and feed produced by the farms and | |||||||
CONAD |
Not present in |
Percorso Qualità Conad |
Controlled feeding; Good farming practices; Internal audit of the full supply chain; Full traceability; Labelling: breeds, age and category (veal, etc.).________________________________ |
Source: our own elaboration on Sans et al. (2004).
The organisational mechanisms adopted by Carrefour group in Italy and Spain seem
very similar. Probably, the market context of such countries, more similar
compared to the French one, justified this behaviour.
In Spain also Auchan adopted a similar mechanism than Carrefour. As shown by
Sans et al. (2004), these common strategic choices of both groups for their beef
supply was not found in France. There, each retail group reacted differently to the
same problem, the BSE crisis, partially because of the hard competition, stressing
the different solutions applied. Whereas in Italy, Auchan- Sma for its product line
“Filiera Controllata ” (Controlled supply chain), has signed the interprofessional
3 Audits are carried out by third part (independent body) and in- house inspections.
16