Tobacco and Alcohol: Complements or Substitutes? - A Statistical Guinea Pig Approach



Harald Tauchmann, Silja Gohlmann, Till Requate
and Christoph M. Schmidt*

Tobacco and Alcohol: Complements or Substitutes? -

A Statistical Guinea Pig Approach

Abstract

The question of whether two drugs - namely alcohol and tobacco - are used as
complements or substitutes is of crucial interest if side-effects of anti-drug pol-
icies are considered. Numerous papers have empirically addressed this issue
by estimating demand systems for alcohol and tobacco and subsequently cal-
culating cross-price effects. However, this traditional approach often is seri-
ously hampered by insufficient price-variation observed in survey data. We,
therefore, suggest an alternative instrumental variables approach that statisti-
cally mimics an experimental study and does not rely on prices as explanatory
variables. This approach is applied to German survey data. Our estimation
results suggest that a reduction in tobacco consumption results in a reduction
in alcohol consumption, too. It is shown theoretically that this implies that
alcohol and tobacco are complements. Hence, we conclude that successful
antismoking policies will not result in the unintended side-effect of an in-
creased (ab)use of alcohol.

JEL Classification: C31, D12, I12

Keywords: Interdependence in consumption, tobacco and alcohol,
instrumental variables approach

November 2006

*Harald Tauchmann, RWI Essen; Silja Gohlmann, RWI Essen; Till Requate, University Kiel;
Christoph M. Schmidt, RWI Essen and Ruhr University Bochum. All correspondence to Harald
Tauchmann, Rheinisch-Westfalisches Institut für Wirtschaftsforschung (RWI Essen), Hohenzol-
lernstr. 1-3, 45128 Essen, Germany. Fax: +49-201-8149-200. Email:
[email protected].
We would like to thank Boris Augurzky and Lars Siemers as well as participants at the Scottish
Economic Society Annual Conference 2006, the European Society for Population Economics
20th Annual Conference, and the Verein für Socialpolitik Annual Conference 2006 for many use-
ful comments. Any errors are our own.



More intriguing information

1. A multistate demographic model for firms in the province of Gelderland
2. Models of Cognition: Neurological possibility does not indicate neurological plausibility.
3. DISCUSSION: ASSESSING STRUCTURAL CHANGE IN THE DEMAND FOR FOOD COMMODITIES
4. Understanding the (relative) fall and rise of construction wages
5. The Values and Character Dispositions of 14-16 Year Olds in the Hodge Hill Constituency
6. THE EFFECT OF MARKETING COOPERATIVES ON COST-REDUCING PROCESS INNOVATION ACTIVITY
7. THE CO-EVOLUTION OF MATTER AND CONSCIOUSNESS1
8. The name is absent
9. The name is absent
10. SOME ISSUES CONCERNING SPECIFICATION AND INTERPRETATION OF OUTDOOR RECREATION DEMAND MODELS
11. Distortions in a multi-level co-financing system: the case of the agri-environmental programme of Saxony-Anhalt
12. The name is absent
13. Telecommuting and environmental policy - lessons from the Ecommute program
14. Measuring Semantic Similarity by Latent Relational Analysis
15. Bargaining Power and Equilibrium Consumption
16. An Attempt to 2
17. PROPOSED IMMIGRATION POLICY REFORM & FARM LABOR MARKET OUTCOMES
18. The Impact of Individual Investment Behavior for Retirement Welfare: Evidence from the United States and Germany
19. The name is absent
20. MATHEMATICS AS AN EXACT AND PRECISE LANGUAGE OF NATURE