Voting by Committees under Constraints



the other with top on 0 (orderings {ж} >~4 B >-4 D, B >b D >-δ {ж}, and
B {x}   D).

Proof of Theorem 1 To prove necessity, let F∙. An —> 2κ be a strategy-
proof social choice function and let
{Bi,..., Bq} be the minimal Cylindric
decomposition of ⅛, which exists by Proposition 3.

(1) Assume that x,y Zi AC(Bp) = {Z1,Z2}. Since {Bi,..., Bq} is
minimal we have that
Zi ∩ Z2 = 0. Assume that W''' ≠ TV™; that is, there
exists
I W''' such that I TV™. Consider any P such that τ(PiBp = Z1
for all i I and τ(Pf) ∩ Bp = Z2 for all j NI. Then, x F(P) and
у <f F(P) contradicting that x and у belong to the same active component
of
Bp.

(2) Assume x A, у Y, and AC(Bp) = {A, У}. To obtain a contra-
diction assume there exists
D W''' and ND TV™. It is easy to find P
such that x, у F(P) contradicting that x and у belong to different active
components of
Bp.

(3) Follows from part (a) of Proposition 4 and Proposition 5.

Sufficiency follows from part (b) of Proposition 4, since it is clear that
all social choice functions defined on each of the sections are onto the active
components of the section and strategy-proof.

6 References

ANSWAL, N., CHATTERJI, S., and SEN, A. (1999). “Dictatorial Do-
mains”, Discussion paper 99-05, Indian Statistical Institute.

BARBERÀ, S., GUL, F., and STACCHETTI, E. (1993). “Generalized Me-
dian Voter Schemes and Committees”,
Journal of Economic Theory, 61,
262-289.

28



More intriguing information

1. The Integration Order of Vector Autoregressive Processes
2. AN EMPIRICAL INVESTIGATION OF THE PRODUCTION EFFECTS OF ADOPTING GM SEED TECHNOLOGY: THE CASE OF FARMERS IN ARGENTINA
3. Nietzsche, immortality, singularity and eternal recurrence1
4. On the Existence of the Moments of the Asymptotic Trace Statistic
5. The name is absent
6. The name is absent
7. The name is absent
8. Wirtschaftslage und Reformprozesse in Estland, Lettland, und Litauen: Bericht 2001
9. The Mathematical Components of Engineering
10. THE EFFECT OF MARKETING COOPERATIVES ON COST-REDUCING PROCESS INNOVATION ACTIVITY