Effort and Performance in Public-Policy Contests



CESifo Working Paper No. 634

January 2002

EFFORT AND PERFORMANCE IN PUBLIC-POLICY
CONTESTS

Abstract

Government intervention often gives rise to contests in which the possible
‘prizes’ are determined by the existing status-quo and some new public-
policy proposal . In this paper we study the general class of such two-player
public-policy contests and examine the effect of a change in the proposed
policy, a change that may affect the payoffs of the two contestants, on their
effort and performance. We extend the existing comparative statics studies
that focus on the effect of changes either in the value of the prize in
symmetric contests or in one of the contestants’ valuation of the prize in
asymmetric contests. Our results hinge on the relationship between the
strategic own-stake (“income”) effect and the strategic rival’s-stake
(“substitution”) effect. This relationship is determined by three types of ability
and stakes asymmetry between the contestants. In particular, we specify the
asymmetry condition under which a more restrained government intervention
that reduces the contestants’ prizes has the perverse effect of increasing
their aggregate lobbying efforts.

Keywords: public-policy contests, policy reforms, lobbying efforts, strategic
own-stake effect, strategic rival’s-stake (“substitution”) effect.

JEL Classification: D72, D6.

Gil S. Epstein
Department of Economics
Bar-Ilan University
52900 Ramat-Gan
Israel

Shmuel Nitzan

Department of Economics
Bar-Ilan University
52900 Ramat-Gan

Israel

[email protected]



More intriguing information

1. The name is absent
2. A Rare Presentation of Crohn's Disease
3. Meat Slaughter and Processing Plants’ Traceability Levels Evidence From Iowa
4. The name is absent
5. The growing importance of risk in financial regulation
6. 5th and 8th grade pupils’ and teachers’ perceptions of the relationships between teaching methods, classroom ethos, and positive affective attitudes towards learning mathematics in Japan
7. A simple enquiry on heterogeneous lending rates and lending behaviour
8. AGRICULTURAL PRODUCERS' WILLINGNESS TO PAY FOR REAL-TIME MESOSCALE WEATHER INFORMATION
9. Momentum in Australian Stock Returns: An Update
10. Estimation of marginal abatement costs for undesirable outputs in India's power generation sector: An output distance function approach.