Infrastructure Investment in Network Industries: The Role of Incentive Regulation and Regulatory Independence



Figure 2 shows that regulators are overwhelmingly independent in the electricity, gas and
telecommunications sectors, while regulators tend to be part of government agencies or ministries
in transportation and in the water industry. Two measures of regulatory independence were
constructed. The first was whether the regulator was independent of the government. The second
measure was a gauge of
de facto independence assessing the extent to which the executive can
influence the regulator’s decisions and operation (using responses from the OECD infrastructure
questionnaire).19 The two variables are not significantly different. The type of price regulation
regime was interacted with the regulator’s independence variable to see whether
complementarities between them matter for sectoral investment.

As questionnaire responses only provide a snapshot of regulation in late 2007 and early 2008, the
data on the type of regulatory regime do not have a time dimension. For this reason, only cross-
sectional regressions are carried out in the analysis (with sectoral investment being the dependent
variable). The regulatory variables include variables capturing the presence of incentive
regulation (inc), the absence of any price regulation (dereg) (unregulated or deregulated), the
presence of an independent sector regulator (ri), and an interaction term of incentive regulation
and regulatory independence (inc*ri). The other explanatory variables are lagged investment
(
It_1), long-term real interest rate ( r ) deflated with sectoral deflators, and variables capturing the
general regulatory environment: entry barriers (
entry )20 and public ownership ( po ).21,22 As a
result, a linearised version of the following investment function was estimated:

I = f ( It 1, r, entry, po, inc, dereg, ri, inc * ri )

(1a)


Investment data are obtained from the OECD’s STAN and SNA (Sectoral National Accounts)
databases. These two databases have two serious shortcomings. Firstly, the level of

19.       The de jure measure of independence was adjusted for the possibility of the executive overruling

the regulator’s decisions. The de facto measure of independence was calculated as the average of
the
de jure independence and the possibility of overruling.

20.       The definition of entry barriers differs across sectors to reflect sector-specific characteristics. For

more details, see Conway and Nicoletti (2006). The data can be downloaded from:

http://www.oecd.org/document/32/0,3343,en 2649 34323 35791136 1 1 1 1,00.html

21.       Entry barriers and public ownership were used in Alesina et al (2005) who performed a panel

data analysis of sectoral investment.

22.       The dependent and explanatory variables are averages for 2001-2006, except the two variables

capturing the regulatory regime (inc and dereg). In addition, the explanatory variables are
included with a lag of one period (using averages for 1995 to 2000), except inc and dereg.

14



More intriguing information

1. Bird’s Eye View to Indonesian Mass Conflict Revisiting the Fact of Self-Organized Criticality
2. The name is absent
3. The name is absent
4. Integrating the Structural Auction Approach and Traditional Measures of Market Power
5. The name is absent
6. Pass-through of external shocks along the pricing chain: A panel estimation approach for the euro area
7. fMRI Investigation of Cortical and Subcortical Networks in the Learning of Abstract and Effector-Specific Representations of Motor Sequences
8. Measuring and Testing Advertising-Induced Rotation in the Demand Curve
9. The name is absent
10. How does an infant acquire the ability of joint attention?: A Constructive Approach
11. Natural Resources: Curse or Blessing?
12. The name is absent
13. A parametric approach to the estimation of cointegration vectors in panel data
14. Mergers under endogenous minimum quality standard: a note
15. Moffett and rhetoric
16. The name is absent
17. Design and investigation of scalable multicast recursive protocols for wired and wireless ad hoc networks
18. A Rational Analysis of Alternating Search and Reflection Strategies in Problem Solving
19. WP 48 - Population ageing in the Netherlands: Demographic and financial arguments for a balanced approach
20. FUTURE TRADE RESEARCH AREAS THAT MATTER TO DEVELOPING COUNTRY POLICYMAKERS