National curriculum assessment: how to make it better



Abstract

In a series of papers ov er the last ten years, I have outlined various problems affecting
the assessment of the national curriculum in England which are the subject of a critique
by Paul Newton (this issue). In responding to this critique, I acknowledge that his
summary of my position is fair, and agree that, by the standards of analytic rationality,
the evidence for some of the problems I identify is not compelling. However, in
response I argue that by standards of reasonableness (eg on the balance of probabilities)
the evidence is sufficently serious to warrant a re-examination of national curriculum
assessment, and the alternatives. In particular, I argue that the current system provides
assessments that are not sufficiently reliable for the inferences that are made on the
basis of the results and has also caused a narrowing of the curriculum. I propose that the
first of these weaknesses can be addressed through the increased use of teacher
assessment, and the second by increasing the range of the curriculum tested through
testing a greater proportion of the curriculum. In order to effect these changes without
increasing the burdern on students and teachers, I propose that these two changes are
combined in the form of a light sampling scheme which would increase both the
reliability and minimise the curricular backwash, although the price paid for this would
be the lack of a direct, transparent and objective link between the results achieved by
individual students on tests and the reported levels of a school’s performance.

Key words

education, national curriculum assessment, reliability, validity, manageability



More intriguing information

1. Job quality and labour market performance
2. The name is absent
3. The name is absent
4. DURABLE CONSUMPTION AS A STATUS GOOD: A STUDY OF NEOCLASSICAL CASES
5. What Contribution Can Residential Field Courses Make to the Education of 11-14 Year-olds?
6. On the job rotation problem
7. The name is absent
8. IMMIGRATION AND AGRICULTURAL LABOR POLICIES
9. The name is absent
10. The name is absent
11. Effort and Performance in Public-Policy Contests
12. Whatever happened to competition in space agency procurement? The case of NASA
13. Proceedings from the ECFIN Workshop "The budgetary implications of structural reforms" - Brussels, 2 December 2005
14. Lumpy Investment, Sectoral Propagation, and Business Cycles
15. Feature type effects in semantic memory: An event related potentials study
16. The name is absent
17. The Composition of Government Spending and the Real Exchange Rate
18. The Distribution of Income of Self-employed, Entrepreneurs and Professions as Revealed from Micro Income Tax Statistics in Germany
19. Disentangling the Sources of Pro-social Behavior in the Workplace: A Field Experiment
20. The Role of area-yield crop insurance program face to the Mid-term Review of Common Agricultural Policy