A Review of Kuhnian and Lakatosian “Explanations” in Economics



economics as being characterized by competing research programmes rather than by one
paradigm.

Hausman engages in a more substantial criticism. He states (1994, p. 199):

“Kuhn’s account of disciplinary matrices provides a checklist of what to look for in
examining the large-scale structures of economic theorizing, but the basic
principles of microeconomics have a different status and role than do Kuhn’s
symbolic generalizations. Consequently, economics does not fit his schema very
well.”

An example of a symbolic generalization in economics is that agents are self-interested.

However, selfish agents are fundamental in much of microeconomics but not in all of it
(Hausman, 1994, p.198). In more general terms, Hausman (1992, p. 84) writes: “The basic
claims of equilibrium theory are not quite symbolic generalizations in Kuhn’s sense, because
economists are not firmly committed to all of them.”

From the above analysis, table 3 presents the main categories of criticism exercised
by historians of economic thought upon Kuhn’s explanation in relation to economics.

Table 3

Criticisms on Kuhn’s explanation

Vagueness In terminology

Non-appropriateness for economics

Stigler, 1969

Bronfenbrener, 1971

Blaug, 1976

Glass and Johnson, 1989

Glass and Johnson, 1989

Hausman, 1992, 1994

Johnson, 1983

Weintraub, 1979

Redman, 1993

11



More intriguing information

1. Nurses' retention and hospital characteristics in New South Wales, CHERE Discussion Paper No 52
2. Sectoral Energy- and Labour-Productivity Convergence
3. Feeling Good about Giving: The Benefits (and Costs) of Self-Interested Charitable Behavior
4. Categorial Grammar and Discourse
5. LOCAL CONTROL AND IMPROVEMENT OF COMMUNITY SERVICE
6. Design and investigation of scalable multicast recursive protocols for wired and wireless ad hoc networks
7. Placentophagia in Nonpregnant Nulliparous Mice: A Genetic Investigation1
8. The Complexity Era in Economics
9. The name is absent
10. The name is absent