A Review of Kuhnian and Lakatosian “Explanations” in Economics



economic thought tried to fit the Kuhnian approach to the development of economics.
However, the first example of the systematic application of Kuhn’s views to economic
thought can be found in Coats (1969). Coats applied Kuhn’s methodological tools to the
history of economic thought. His main conclusion was that there has been only one
paradigm: equilibrium theory based on the idea of market mechanism. Some years later,
Loasby (1971) argued that there exists the profit-maximization paradigm in economics, while
an emerging paradigm could be the behavioural theory of the firm.

The next systematic application of Kuhnian views was provided by B. Ward (1972).
He adopts some of Kuhn’s criteria in order to examine if economics can be characterised
as a mature science much like physics. His reference is the orthodox neoclassical theory.
In his view, the existence of an “invisible college” of neoclassical economists with
common method and agreement concerning what are the important problems of the field,
indicate the maturity of neoclassical economics. Furthermore, he continues to find puzzle-
solving behaviour giving as a prime example of the classical versus the marginalist theory
of value. Apart from the Neoclassical school, Ward examines the development of Marxian
economics. He discerns some puzzle-solving behaviour especially with regard to the issue
of values and prices. However, he believes that it fits less to the Kuhnian framework since
he is unable to find examples of crises and scientific revolutions. As he writes “[Marxism]
passes most of the tests necessary for a Marxist economic science to exist in the Kuhnian
test, but in practice it has failed because of the virtual absence of an integrated social
system of scientists oriented toward the systematic development of the science through
study of problems of detail” (1972, p. 70).

Dow (1981) claimed that general equilibrium analysis must rather be considered as a
Kuhnian paradigm. A few years later and in more general terms, Dow (1985) uses Kuhnian



More intriguing information

1. Global Excess Liquidity and House Prices - A VAR Analysis for OECD Countries
2. WP RR 17 - Industrial relations in the transport sector in the Netherlands
3. Sustainability of economic development and governance patterns in water management - an overview on the reorganisation of public utilities in Campania, Italy, under EU Framework Directive in the field of water policy (2000/60/CE)
4. The name is absent
5. Keynesian Dynamics and the Wage-Price Spiral:Estimating a Baseline Disequilibrium Approach
6. ¿Por qué se privatizan servicios en los municipios (pequeños)? Evidencia empírica sobre residuos sólidos y agua.
7. The name is absent
8. The name is absent
9. ISO 9000 -- A MARKETING TOOL FOR U.S. AGRIBUSINESS
10. The Effects of Reforming the Chinese Dual-Track Price System
11. MATHEMATICS AS AN EXACT AND PRECISE LANGUAGE OF NATURE
12. Political Rents, Promotion Incentives, and Support for a Non-Democratic Regime
13. The name is absent
14. The name is absent
15. The name is absent
16. A Note on Costly Sequential Search and Oligopoly Pricing (new title: Truly Costly Sequential Search and Oligopolistic Pricing,)
17. IMMIGRATION AND AGRICULTURAL LABOR POLICIES
18. Der Einfluß der Direktdemokratie auf die Sozialpolitik
19. Constructing the Phylomemetic Tree Case of Study: Indonesian Tradition-Inspired Buildings
20. The name is absent