of loans remains income-contingent, with debt write-off after 25 years, but the
interest rate subsidy is effectively eliminated by the charging of interest of 2.5%
pa above inflation on the debt.
• Variant 2: “NZ” system: under this variant, similar to the one currently in
place in New Zealand, the repayment of loans also remains income-contingent,
with debt write-off after 25 years, and the interest rate subsidy is eliminated by the
charging of interest of 2.5% pa above inflation on the debt. However when
earnings are low, the income-contingent repayment amount may be too low to
cover the interest element of the loan. In this case, the government would pay on
behalf of the borrower the additional interest due, meaning that the outstanding
balance on the loan would be prevented from spiralling during periods of low
earnings.
Our calculations suggest that the removal of the interest subsidy (i.e. a switch from
the new system to variant 1) would amount to the equivalent of the removal of an
average up-front grant of around £2,465 for each female graduate and £2,880 for each
male graduate (whilst the additional cost to the graduate of the “NZ system” relative
to the new system would be around £1,940 and £2,280 respectively).
However, as can be seen from Table , these savings for the exchequer, and costs to the
graduate would be highest for men in the 2nd to 4th deciles of the male lifetime
earnings distribution, and for women at the 6th and 7th, deciles of the female earnings
distribution. The very lowest female earners would lose relatively little from the
removal of the interest subsidy, since many are protected by the provision for debt
write-off after 25 years.
Table . Average additional costs to graduates of removing interest subsidies,
relative to new system, by decile of the lifetime earnings distribution________ | ||
Decile of |
Variant 1, |
Variant 2, |
Poorest 2nd 3rd |
Additional cost to graduate F M £371 £2,924 £1,016 £3,491 £1,827 £3,390 |
Additional cost to graduate £299 £2,118 £819 £2,578 £1,450 £2,539 |
24
More intriguing information
1. The name is absent2. Gender and aquaculture: sharing the benefits equitably
3. Insurance within the firm
4. ‘I’m so much more myself now, coming back to work’ - working class mothers, paid work and childcare.
5. The name is absent
6. Cyclical Changes in Short-Run Earnings Mobility in Canada, 1982-1996
7. The name is absent
8. Co-ordinating European sectoral policies against the background of European Spatial Development
9. Research Design, as Independent of Methods
10. The Impact of Optimal Tariffs and Taxes on Agglomeration