Table 1: Average Number of Asylum Applications per Year, 1985-99
(per thousand of population)
HIGHEST |
LOWEST | ||||||
Switzerland |
3.35 |
Belgium |
1.41 |
Australia |
0.36 |
Spain______ |
0.17 |
Sweden |
2.64 |
Norway |
1.23 |
Ireland |
0.33 |
Czech Rep. |
0.16 |
Germany |
2.03 |
Canada |
0.97 |
Greece |
0.31 |
Italy_________ |
0.15 |
Denmark |
1.81 |
EU15 |
0.96 |
US_____ |
0.28 |
Portugal |
0.05 |
Netherlands |
1.63 |
France |
0.55 |
Finland |
0.24 |
Poland |
0.03 |
Austria |
1,62 |
UK |
0,46 |
Hungary |
0,19 |
Japan______ |
____0 |
Against the background of the serious collective action problems involved
in this area, the German government in 1992 proposed a European wide
asylum burden-sharing system. The German proposal8 foresaw the
distribution of asylum seekers across Europe according to indicative
figures that were based on a distribution key composed of three criteria
which were given equal weight (population size, size of Member State
territory and GDP).9 The centrepiece of the German draft was the
introduction of a compulsory resettlement mechanism which would have
worked as follows: ‘Where the numbers admitted by a Member State
exceeds its indicative figure [...], other Member States which have not yet
reached their indicative figure [...] will accept persons from the first
State’.10 This proposal, however, did not find the necessary support among
other countries, with the UK in particular being strongly opposed to such
a scheme.11
Since then, European states have instead agreed on a number of (limited)
steps towards harmonising asylum policy regulations across Europe,
8 Council Document 7773/94 ASIM 124.
9 The form of the suggested redistributive mechanism followed the example of German
domestic legislation, which stipulates a similar key for the distribution of asylum seekers
among the German Lander. See section 45 of the German Asylum Procedure Act
(Asylverfahrensgesetz).
10 Council Document 7773/94 ASIM 124.
11 BMI, Pressemitteilung vom 1.12.1994, FAZ 27.1.1995, p.2; BT-Drs. 13/1070, 55;
Integrationsbericht, p.92.