Gardner and Young
Salinity Control Evaluation
TABLE 2. Municipal Damages from Salinity, or Municipal Benefits of Salinity Control.
Total Lower Basin |
Metro Water |
Arizona Project |
Lower Main- |
Annual Damage Per Household | |||
(1982 $/mg/liter) Number of Full Service Equivalent Households |
$0.2442 |
$0.1655 |
$0.1677 |
1983-87 1,820,000 |
1,570,000 |
0 |
250,000 |
1988-2032 1,092,000 Annual Benefits of Salinity Control Lagged Benefits8 218,700 |
597,000 |
245,000 |
250,000 |
Source: adapted from USBR, 1980.
a Lagged benefits have been discounted to reflect approximate six-year retention time of the reservoir system
between the upstream project locations and the points of use.
agriculture in the entire Lower Colorado
Basin by accepting the USBR (1980) esti-
mate that Imperial Valley damages are
about 90 percent of the total. This as-
sumption translates to (in 1982 dollars)
$51,400 per mg∕liter damages to agricul-
ture in the Lower Basin.
We further adjust for the hydraulic re-
tention time of the river and reservoir sys-
tem. Using the hydrologic assumptions
described above and an eight percent dis-
count rate, the present value of total an-
nual agricultural benefits of salinity con-
trol becomes $39,100 per mg∕liter or $3.95
per ton of salt removed. (We adopted the
view that the social discount rate should
reflect, in this case, the opportunity cost
of displaced private spending, further ad-
justed for the high risks of salinity control
projects. Our chosen rate also closely ap-
proximates the Water Resources Council
mandated rate for fiscal year 1983.)
Municipal Benefits
Due to limitations on research re-
sources, this analysis utilizes previous re-
ports (Anderson and Kleinman, 1978:19;
d’Arge and Eubanks; and U.S. Bureau of
Reclamation, 1980) for estimates of the
municipal benefits of salinity control.
Those estimates were based on cross-sec-
tional surveys of Lower Basin cities whose
water supplies differ in salinity. Plumbers
and appliance dealers in each area were
asked to estimate average lifetimes of var-
ious plumbing fixtures and water using
appliances. Generally, the lower the salin-
ity of the water the less often fixtures must
be replaced, and the less the salinity dam-
ages. In addition to capital replacement
costs, estimated damages avoided include
the costs of bottled water, additional de-
tergents, and central water softening
needed to mitigate the more saline water.
The annual costs per household are con-
verted to 1982 dollars and listed in Ta-
ble 2.
The costs must be multiplied by the
number of households to get annual area
municipal damages. Estimates of house-
hold numbers are taken from USBR (1980:
14). (In practice, Colorado River water is
often blended to lower the concentration
below the recommended level of 500 mg∕
liter. Therefore, an estimate of equivalent
full service households which could be
served solely with Colorado River water
is used.) For the Metropolitan Water Dis-
trict of southern California 1,052,000 acre-
feet of water are assumed to be used an-
nually for municipal purposes, with a
cutback to 400,000 acre-feet after 1987.
Annual use is assumed to be 0.67 acre-feet
per household.
An estimate of 245,000 full service
More intriguing information
1. The name is absent2. Indirect Effects of Pesticide Regulation and the Food Quality Protection Act
3. Foreign Direct Investment and the Single Market
4. How does an infant acquire the ability of joint attention?: A Constructive Approach
5. The name is absent
6. DEVELOPING COLLABORATION IN RURAL POLICY: LESSONS FROM A STATE RURAL DEVELOPMENT COUNCIL
7. The Complexity Era in Economics
8. Centre for Longitudinal Studies
9. Does South Africa Have the Potential and Capacity to Grow at 7 Per Cent?: A Labour Market Perspective
10. ISO 9000 -- A MARKETING TOOL FOR U.S. AGRIBUSINESS