A Critical Examination of the Beliefs about Learning a Foreign Language at Primary School



Eariy or even simultaneous introduction Ofwritten language can support rather
than hinder progress. Burstall had reported that many children complained:

"...that they cannot remember words unless they see them written down
and, ∞nsequently, experience considerable difficulty during the oral phase of
learning French." (Burstall, 1970: 54)

In the 1990s spoken language still takes on a primary role in early foreign
language schemes and reading and writing are frequently not introduced until
the second or even the third year of foreign language learning. Very recently it
is reported from Council of Europe workshops that:

"...in the first years the young learners spend most of the time listening to and
speaking in the foreign language..." (Ytreberg, 1997: 30)

It is further stated that:

"A wholly oral approach, which is possible for a longer period at this early stage
and which may be less acceptable later, allows more pupils to succeed in
modem language work." (Trim, quoted in Doye & Hurrell, 1997:12)

Such comments, as well as the motives behind them, would seem highly
questionable. They seem at best optimistic and at worst counterproductive and
obscure some of the real issues at hand, such as the definition of success, what
∞nstitutes modem language ,work, and whether younger is indeed better.

178



More intriguing information

1. THE RISE OF RURAL-TO-RURAL LABOR MARKETS IN CHINA
2. Reputations, Market Structure, and the Choice of Quality Assurance Systems in the Food Industry
3. The role of statin drugs in combating cardiovascular diseases
4. The name is absent
5. Magnetic Resonance Imaging in patients with ICDs and Pacemakers
6. Deletion of a mycobacterial gene encoding a reductase leads to an altered cell wall containing β-oxo-mycolic acid analogues, and the accumulation of long-chain ketones related to mycolic acids
7. A Rational Analysis of Alternating Search and Reflection Strategies in Problem Solving
8. The Demand for Specialty-Crop Insurance: Adverse Selection and Moral Hazard
9. Optimal Private and Public Harvesting under Spatial and Temporal Interdependence
10. Labour Market Flexibility and Regional Unemployment Rate Dynamics: Spain (1980-1995)