A Critical Examination of the Beliefs about Learning a Foreign Language at Primary School



observations of immigrants entering Canada who, as children, seemed to
acquire the target language effortlessly. His comments quite clearly ignored
crucial contextual differences and display a confusion between the processes
involved in the acquisition of a first language, in acquiring a second language in
naturalistic environments and the learning of a foreign language in the
classroom. In any case, as Harley pointed out, the ability of the damaged brain
to regain lost or disrupted language:

"...is not necessarily related to the ability of the healthy brain to acquire a new
L2." (Harley, 1986: 5)

Lenneberg1S timing of the process of lateralization was also questioned by

Krashen (1973) who suggested that lateralization might be completed by the

age of four or five. Since much language learning takes place after that age the
relationship between a critical period and lateralization remains questionable:

"The evidence, then, appears to call for a revision of the critical period
hypothesis as originally put forth. If its biological basis is the lateralization of
language function, then the critical period for language development would
seem to occur between the ages of 2 and 4 or 5. A great deal of syntax is
acquired during this time span but ...by no means all syntax. Nor is
phonological or semantic development complete by the age of 4 or 5. To
assert that the child acquires language during this period of time seems to be
too strong a claim." (McLaughlin, 1984:48)

The essential question that remains for second language learning then is

'whether a general "matrix for language skills" which Lenneberg suggested was

65



More intriguing information

1. Contribution of Economics to Design of Sustainable Cattle Breeding Programs in Eastern Africa: A Choice Experiment Approach
2. The name is absent
3. Fertility in Developing Countries
4. Determinants of U.S. Textile and Apparel Import Trade
5. The name is absent
6. Naïve Bayes vs. Decision Trees vs. Neural Networks in the Classification of Training Web Pages
7. The name is absent
8. Government spending composition, technical change and wage inequality
9. The migration of unskilled youth: Is there any wage gain?
10. From Communication to Presence: Cognition, Emotions and Culture towards the Ultimate Communicative Experience. Festschrift in honor of Luigi Anolli