Commuting in multinodal urban systems: An empirical comparison of three alternative models



Table 6         The relationship between the potential population and

employment density functions and actual distances (correlation
coefficients - R2)

daily urban
system

Potential                                Employment

population

Amsterdam

Utrecht
Rotterdam

The Hague

0.07                                      0.19

0.47                                       0.48

0.44                                       0.46

0.65                                       0.59

Another reason for the failing of the basic concentrated model is, of course, that actual
behaviour of commuters does not satisfy the presuppositions of the model. Because the
monocentric model starts from rather rigid presuppositions, the removal of these, lowers the
degree of wastefulness and by this increases the level of explanation by the adapted model.
That all commuting is towards the centre is one of these presuppositions. Wastefulness should
be seen in a broader framework of ‘other factors’ which co-determine the locational choice
(Waddell 1993). If these are incorporated in a model which determines the minimal distance,
it is possible to increase its explanatory power. One such effort is the cross-traffic model.
This model makes room for traffic not - direct or indirect - oriented at the centre of the
urban region and is connected to the second main question of this article: is it possible to
adapt the basic model in such a way that it becomes more in accordance with the actual
behaviour of commuters?

20



More intriguing information

1. Confusion and Reinforcement Learning in Experimental Public Goods Games
2. THE INTERNATIONAL OUTLOOK FOR U.S. TOBACCO
3. Strategic Effects and Incentives in Multi-issue Bargaining Games
4. The name is absent
5. THE WELFARE EFFECTS OF CONSUMING A CANCER PREVENTION DIET
6. ROBUST CLASSIFICATION WITH CONTEXT-SENSITIVE FEATURES
7. Implementation of a 3GPP LTE Turbo Decoder Accelerator on GPU
8. SOME ISSUES IN LAND TENURE, OWNERSHIP AND CONTROL IN DISPERSED VS. CONCENTRATED AGRICULTURE
9. Foreign Direct Investment and Unequal Regional Economic Growth in China
10. Estimated Open Economy New Keynesian Phillips Curves for the G7