Federal Tax-Transfer Policy and Intergovernmental Pre-Commitment



constraint (6) with respect to ti and the federal policy instruments si and τ :

∂ti                ∂ti

b00 ( gi )

∂ti ( ⅛ ´ - b00 (gi)gi


(12)


— = 0 and —-
∂τ             ∂si

A change in the federal tax rate does not affect the choice of ti, i.e. state i’s best-response
effectively is
ti = ti (si). To sign state i’s reaction to a marginal increase in transfers, note that,
by the second-order condition of the state’s optimization problem, the denominator is positive.
This together with the assumption
b00(gi) < 0 implies that state i’s capital tax rate is decreasing
in the amount of transfers received.

Federal Government The federal government solves:

max L = X Vi(τ, ti, tj ,tiki + sl) + μ X (sl — τli)

s1,s2           i=1,2                                      i=1,2

subject to {ki = ki (ti , tj)}i=1,2 i6=j , {li = li (τ)}i=1,2 , and {ti = ti (si)}i=1,2 . The first-order
conditions are

si :   Vig + Vjtjsi + Vgjgjtsi + μ = 0 and τ :   X(Vi + μ(-li — τll7- =0,     i= j, (13)

i=1,2

which have already been simplified using Vtii + Vgigtii tisi = 0 (by Eq. (8)). Imposing symmetry,
inserting Eq. (5) and rearranging, the first-order conditions reduce to

1

b0(g)(1+ gtitisi) = 1> 1,     i= j.                       (14)

Unlike the case of Nash-behavior the federal government anticipates a reduction in ti when rais-
ing
si . The induced inflow of capital in state j increases tax revenues in state j as captured by
the term
gtji tisi . Since the federal government considers the substitution of own state tax revenues
by federal transfers (financed by distortionary labor taxes ) as undesirable, the strategic effect
increases the marginal cost of labor taxation; yielding a lower labor tax (and thus transfers) and
by Eq. (12) a higher capital tax. Denoting (
tc, τc, sc) and (tN , τN , sN) the optimal policy under
centralized leadership and Nash-behavior, respectively, we can state the following result:

14



More intriguing information

1. Workforce or Workfare?
2. Ronald Patterson, Violinist; Brooks Smith, Pianist
3. Auction Design without Commitment
4. How Offshoring Can Affect the Industries’ Skill Composition
5. Does Competition Increase Economic Efficiency in Swedish County Councils?
6. Learning-by-Exporting? Firm-Level Evidence for UK Manufacturing and Services Sectors
7. The name is absent
8. MICROWORLDS BASED ON LINEAR EQUATION SYSTEMS: A NEW APPROACH TO COMPLEX PROBLEM SOLVING AND EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS
9. AMINO ACIDS SEQUENCE ANALYSIS ON COLLAGEN
10. THE MEXICAN HOG INDUSTRY: MOVING BEYOND 2003