202 Social Capital and the Food System: Some Evidences from Empirical Research
Table 1. Different structural and strategic traits of the industry in the two districts
Distinctive district traits__________ |
Emilia_________________________ |
Campania_________________________ |
Main product________________ |
paste_____________________________ |
Peel canned tomato whole peeled_______ |
Own brand________________ |
Seldom used__________________ |
Often used___________________________ |
Grower |
Many of small dimension; high |
Many of small dimension; low cohesion; |
Processors |
Few of medium dimension |
Few of large dimension and many of |
Vertical relationships____________ |
Collaborative_____________________ |
Competitive____________________________ |
Main customers |
Big buyers and large retailers |
Own brand processors, large retailers |
Vertical coordination through |
High |
Absent |
Transparency and accountability |
High |
Low |
Weakness |
Slow modernization process; Cost disadvantages Organizational rigidities of |
Short-period competitive advantages; Fragmented structure Weak infrastructures |
Strength |
Strong relationships with big High quality (certification, |
Trading skill Knowledge of the market |
Distinctive district traits__________ |
Emilia_________________________ |
Campania_________________________ |
Main product________________ |
paste_____________________________ |
Peel canned tomato whole peeled_______ |
Own brand________________ |
Seldom used__________________ |
Often used___________________________ |
Grower |
Many of small dimension; high |
Many of small dimension; low cohesion; |
Processors |
Few of medium dimension |
Few of large dimension and many of |
Vertical relationships____________ |
Collaborative_____________________ |
Competitive____________________________ |
Main customers |
Big buyers and large retailers |
Own brand processors, large retailers |
Vertical coordination through |
High |
Absent |
Transparency and accountability |
High |
Low |
Weakness |
Slow modernization process; Cost disadvantages Organizational rigidities of |
Short-period competitive advantages; Fragmented structure Weak infrastructures |
Strength |
Strong relationships with big High quality (certification, |
Trading skill Knowledge of the market |
In the 1980s and 1990s the Italian processing tomato industry performed very successfully,
mainly because of the demand increase and the EU subsidy regime. This latter particularly
boosted the Campania district due to growers’ and processors’ fraudulent overstatement of
tomato purchases, the so-called ‘paper’ or ‘ghost’ tomato. At least 15 per cent of southern
tomato factories seem to have been involved in such fraud. At the dawn of the new millennium