Elicited bid functions in (a)symmetric first-price auctions



the RANE bidding strategies, we treat r as a “natural constant” and set it equal to .5, which is
in the mid-range of the estimates reported in the literature.6

Tables 2 and 3 report the nodes corresponding to the RNNE and the RANE bid functions for
our three treatments. Note that since in our experiments, bidders’ strategies are not
differentiable, the common bid ceiling requirement for continuous and differentiable bidding
strategies does no more necessarily hold.7 Another point worth noting is that the asymmetry
in the MIX treatment combines low-balling with the “
Getty effect” so that it represents an
intermediate case between the LOW treatment in which low-balling is important and the SYM
treatment where there is no incentive at all to low-ball. Further, the equilibrium strategy for
Strong bidders in MIX is almost identical to the one of Strong bidders in the LOW treatment.
However, the equilibrium strategies for Weak bidders are very different across treatments.
This allows us to assess both the extent of low-balling by Strong bidders and the response of
Weak bidders in different bidding environments.

Table 1 - Treatment Parameters

Treatment

Strong bidder’s
range of values

Is = [Vs , vs ]

Weak bidder’s
range of values
Iw = [ Vw-vw]

Independent
observations

subjects per
independent
observation

number of rounds
per subject

LOW

[0, +100]

[-100, +100]

________9_________

________6

________100

MIX

[0, +100]

[-75, +75]

________9_________

________6

________100

SYM

[0, +100]

[0, +100]

________6_________

________6

________100

6 Goeree et al. (2002) report an estimate of .48 for two-bidder auctions. Cox and Oaxaca (1996) and Chen and
Plott (1998) report estimates of .33 and .52 for auctions with 4 and 3 bidders, assuming heterogeneous risk
preferences. Pezanis-Christou and Romeu (2002) report average estimates of homogenous risk preferences that
range between .39 and 1 for auctions with 3, 4 and 5 bidders.

7 The RNNE best response tracing procedure for the LOW treatment converges to a cycle in which the y2
coordinates of both bidders switch between 30 and 31.



More intriguing information

1. Placenta ingestion by rats enhances y- and n-opioid antinociception, but suppresses A-opioid antinociception
2. The name is absent
3. The Impact of Optimal Tariffs and Taxes on Agglomeration
4. Competition In or For the Field: Which is Better
5. The name is absent
6. Commitment devices, opportunity windows, and institution building in Central Asia
7. The Variable-Rate Decision for Multiple Inputs with Multiple Management Zones
8. Types of Tax Concessions for Promoting Investment in Free Economic and Trade Areas
9. The fundamental determinants of financial integration in the European Union
10. The name is absent