The name is absent



12


Stata Technical Bulletin


STB-57


2. Let I be the current step number. Remove fcθ l'' values from the right end of the original Yi and estimate Δ^ based on
this trimmed set of
n — fc∩ -1^ values: {Yi,..., Y ɔ/-1 ;}. Construct the next set of centered values

v                  v ,     , п—Kq 'j

γV=Yi-∆W, i = l,...,n

and estimate feθŋ using the chosen estimator for k0 applied to the set of values Yil

3. Increment I and repeat step 2 until an iteration L where = fcθb-1 Assign this common value to be the estimated
value fc0. Note that in this iteration it will also be true that ʌ(ɪə =
Δ^l-1

4. Augment (that is, “fill”) the dataset Y with the ко imputed symmetric values

y∕ = 2∆W-yn.j+1, j = l,...,k0

and imputed standard errors

σ*=σn-j+ι, j = l,...,k0

Estimate the “trimmed and filled” value of Δ using the chosen meta-analysis method applied to the full augmented dataset
{y1,...,yn,y1*,...,κ≈}.

Conceptually, this algorithm starts with the observed data, iteratively trims (that is, removes) extreme positive studies from
the dataset until the remaining studies do not show detectable deviation from symmetry, fills (that is, imputes into the original
dataset) studies that are left-side mirrored reflections (about the center of the trimmed data) of the trimmed studies and, finally,
repeats the meta-analysis on the filled dataset to get “trimmed and filled” estimates. Each filled study is assigned the same
standard error as the trimmed study it reflects in order to maintain symmetry within the filled dataset.

Example

The method is illustrated with an example from the literature that examines the association between Chlamydia trachomatis
and oral contraceptive use derived from 29 case-control studies (Cottingham and Hunter 1992). Analysis of these data with the
publication bias tests of Begg and Mazumdar
(p = 0.115) and Egger et al. (p = 0.016), as provided in metabias, suggests
that publication bias may affect the data. To examine the potential impact of publication bias on the interpretation of the data,
metatrim is invoked as follows:

. metatrim Iogor varlogor, reffeet funnel var

The random-effects model and display of the optional funnel graph are requested via options ref feet and funnel. Option var
is required because the data were provided as log-odds ratios and variances. By default, the linear estimator,
L0, is used to
estimate fc0, as no other estimator was requested. metatrim provides the following output:

Note: option "var"
Meta-analysis

I Pooled

Method I     Est

specified.

987. CI
Lower Upper

Asymptotic
z-value p-value

No. of
studies

Fixed I

Random I

0.655

0.716

0.871

0.898

0.738

0.837

18.389

11.694

0.000

0.000

29

Test for heterogeneity: Q= 37.034 on 28 degrees of freedom (p= 0.118)

Moment-based estimate of between studies variance = 0.021

Trimming estimator: Linear

Meta-analysis type: Random-effects model

iteration I

estimate

Tn

# to trim

diff

----------+-

1            I

0.716

288

S

438

2         I

0.673

308

6

40

3         I

0.660

313

7

16

4         I

0.646

320

7

14

8         I

0.646

320

7

0

Filled

Meta-analysis

I

Method I

Pooled

Est

987.
Lower

CI

Upper

Asymptotic
z-value p-value

No. of
studies

Fixed I

Random I

0.624

0.6SS

0.842

0.831

0.708

0.779

14.969

10.374

0.000

0.000

36

Test for heterogeneity: Q= 49.412 on 35 degrees of freedom (p= 0.054)

Moment-based estimate of between studies variance = 0.031



More intriguing information

1. Constrained School Choice
2. A dynamic approach to the tendency of industries to cluster
3. Text of a letter
4. Informal Labour and Credit Markets: A Survey.
5. A simple enquiry on heterogeneous lending rates and lending behaviour
6. Should informal sector be subsidised?
7. Evolution of cognitive function via redeployment of brain areas
8. CHANGING PRICES, CHANGING CIGARETTE CONSUMPTION
9. The name is absent
10. Two-Part Tax Controls for Forest Density and Rotation Time
11. The name is absent
12. Analyse des verbraucherorientierten Qualitätsurteils mittels assoziativer Verfahren am Beispiel von Schweinefleisch und Kartoffeln
13. The bank lending channel of monetary policy: identification and estimation using Portuguese micro bank data
14. El impacto espacial de las economías de aglomeración y su efecto sobre la estructura urbana.El caso de la industria en Barcelona, 1986-1996
15. The Importance of Global Shocks for National Policymakers: Rising Challenges for Central Banks
16. The name is absent
17. Strategic Effects and Incentives in Multi-issue Bargaining Games
18. How Low Business Tax Rates Attract Multinational Headquarters: Municipality-Level Evidence from Germany
19. The InnoRegio-program: a new way to promote regional innovation networks - empirical results of the complementary research -
20. Economic Evaluation of Positron Emission Tomography (PET) in Non Small Cell Lung Cancer (NSCLC), CHERE Working Paper 2007/6