Towards a framework for critical citizenship education



dialectically connected with ‘how notions of consciousness, ideology, and power enter into
the way human beings constitute their day-to-day realities’ (Giroux 1980, p. 348). While
Zaman (2006, p. 15) considers the practical implementation of Giroux’s conceptions ‘an
impossible mission for institutions established, managed and financially supported by the
state’, they are helpful in the development of a framework for critical citizenship
education.

A Framework for Critical Citizenship Education

As highlighted above, writers in the fields of citizenship education, critical pedagogy and
critical thinking have developed a plethora of concepts and models to categorise and
conceptualise critical citizenship. It is, however, possible to synthesise the literature to
establish a ‘framework’ for analysing and comparing curricula which promote forms of
critical citizenship. To allow us to identify and compare the features of critical pedagogy
and citizenship education reviewed above, we have developed Table 1. This maps the key
descriptors of critical pedagogy along the horizontal axis against the curricular
manifestations on the vertical axis.

The four distinctive elements of critical pedagogy shown in Figure 1, above, form
the horizontal categories of Table 1: politics/ideology, social/collective, self/subjectivity
and praxis/engagement. For the vertical categories, we have used Cogan, Morris and
Print’s (2002, p. 4) useful definition of citizenship / civics education as the formation of
‘the knowledge, skills, values and dispositions of citizens’. These terms can represent both
individualistic attributes (for example, individual knowledge and skills) and the culture or
‘ethos’ (McLaughlin 2005) of an educational context (for example, communal values or
dispositions). They are arguably conventional rather than radical terms, broadly reflecting
the categories used in national curriculum documents. However, the use of this curricular

18



More intriguing information

1. Urban Green Space Policies: Performance and Success Conditions in European Cities
2. BARRIERS TO EFFICIENCY AND THE PRIVATIZATION OF TOWNSHIP-VILLAGE ENTERPRISES
3. Midwest prospects and the new economy
4. Labour Market Flexibility and Regional Unemployment Rate Dynamics: Spain (1980-1995)
5. The name is absent
6. Bidding for Envy-Freeness: A Procedural Approach to n-Player Fair Division Problems
7. A Critical Examination of the Beliefs about Learning a Foreign Language at Primary School
8. Fiscal federalism and Fiscal Autonomy: Lessons for the UK from other Industrialised Countries
9. The Context of Sense and Sensibility
10. Antidote Stocking at Hospitals in North Palestine
11. The name is absent
12. Passing the burden: corporate tax incidence in open economies
13. A Hybrid Neural Network and Virtual Reality System for Spatial Language Processing
14. The name is absent
15. The name is absent
16. The name is absent
17. ESTIMATION OF EFFICIENT REGRESSION MODELS FOR APPLIED AGRICULTURAL ECONOMICS RESEARCH
18. CONSUMER ACCEPTANCE OF GENETICALLY MODIFIED FOODS
19. Density Estimation and Combination under Model Ambiguity
20. The name is absent