The ultimate determinants of central bank independence



III.2. The Rogoff Theorem

First, we reproduce Rogoff’s (1985) proof that it is optimal for society (principal) to select
an agent to head the independent central bank that places a large, but finite weight on
inflation. The
optimal degree of central bank independence ε* is defined as that value of ε
that minimizes the expected value of the loss function of society E
t—1 LtI.

To solve for the value of ε that minimizes Et—1 LtI, differentiate (3.2) with respect to ε

d Et-1LtI = ∂Πi + ∂Γi
∂ε       ∂ε     ∂ε

(3.3)

(3.4)


(3.5)


∂γi =     χ2(ι -β)2σJ

[(i + ε)(i -β )2 + χ]3

∂Π _     -χ2u2

dχ     (1+ε)3(1 -β )2

We are now ready to prove:

PROPOSITION 3.1: With a positive natural rate of unemployment, the optimal degree of
central bank independence lies between
zero and infinity (For U>0, 0<ε*<).

Proof: Note that ε > —1 by assumption. Thus, by inspection of (3.5), ∂ΠI∂ε is strictly
negative. Note also, by inspection of (3.4), that
∂ΓI∂ε is strictly negative for

[χ + (1 β) ] < g < о zero when ε = 0 and positive for ε > 0.

(1 -β )2                 ’

Therefore, Et-1 Lt1∂ε is strictly negative for ε 0. Et-1 Lt1Z∂ε must change from
negative to positive at some sufficiently large value of ε, since as ε approaches positive
infinity,
∂ΓI∂ε converges to zero at rate ε-2, whereas ∂ΠI∂ε converges to zero at rate
ε-3. Consequently, ε* < 
7)

The intuition behind this result is the following. From (3.5) it can be seen that increasing
the central bank’s commitment to inflation stabilization decreases the credibility compo-
nent of the social loss function. On the other hand, from (3.4) it follows that having a
more independent central bank increases the stabilization component of the loss

7) As pointed out by Rogoff (1985, p. 1178), it is extremely difficult to write down a closed-form solution
for ɛ*.



More intriguing information

1. Measuring Semantic Similarity by Latent Relational Analysis
2. Secondary stress in Brazilian Portuguese: the interplay between production and perception studies
3. Evidence on the Determinants of Foreign Direct Investment: The Case of Three European Regions
4. The name is absent
5. The name is absent
6. The name is absent
7. Evolving robust and specialized car racing skills
8. Economie de l’entrepreneur faits et théories (The economics of entrepreneur facts and theories)
9. Confusion and Reinforcement Learning in Experimental Public Goods Games
10. The name is absent