A parametric approach to the estimation of cointegration vectors in panel data



First we consider the case of uncorrelated errors, that is, Q = I . It turns
out that for small
T all tests have a tendency to reject the null hypothesis
b = 1 too often.4 The size bias is most severe for the DOLS procedure. If
the errors are generated with a contemporaneous correlation using
Q 6= I ,
then the usual
t-statistics based on the assumption of i.i.d. errors (2S-OLS)
rejects the null hypothesis much too often. The use of robust standard errors
as in (15) reduces the size bias of the test drastically although a moderate
tendency to over-reject the null hypothesis remains if
T is small. In contrast,
the standard errors of the DOLS procedure are seriously over-estimated if
the errors are contemporaneously correlated. Consequently, the test based
on the DOLS procedure has a severe (negative) size bias.

7 Conclusions

In this paper, a parametric approach for estimation and inference in coin-
tegrated panel data models is suggested. Following Ahn and Reinsel (1990)
and Engle and Yoo (1991), an asymptotically efficient estimator is proposed,
where all individual specific short-run parameters are estimated in the first
step and the long-run parameters are estimated from a pooled regression in
a second step. A test procedure is suggested that allows to test the number
of cointegrating relationships and a likelihood ratio statistic is proposed that
allows to test hypotheses on the long-run parameters. Monte Carlo simu-
lations demonstrate that the parametric approach is much more effective in
reducing the small sample bias than the FM-OLS of Pedroni (1995, 2000)
and Phillips and Moon (1999) or the DOLS estimator suggested by Kao and
Chiang (2000). Furthermore, the estimated standard errors of the two-step
estimator can easily be adjusted to account for heteroskedasticity and con-
temporaneous correlation of the errors, a feature that is often encountered
in cross-country studies.

4The standard errors of the FM-OLS estimators computed by the NPT 1.1 program
produces implausibly small values yielding an empirical size close to one.

14



More intriguing information

1. If our brains were simple, we would be too simple to understand them.
2. Labour Market Flexibility and Regional Unemployment Rate Dynamics: Spain (1980-1995)
3. Income Taxation when Markets are Incomplete
4. The name is absent
5. Økonomisk teorihistorie - Overflødig information eller brugbar ballast?
6. Ruptures in the probability scale. Calculation of ruptures’ values
7. Emissions Trading, Electricity Industry Restructuring and Investment in Pollution Abatement
8. Evaluation of the Development Potential of Russian Cities
9. Valuing Access to our Public Lands: A Unique Public Good Pricing Experiment
10. Large Scale Studies in den deutschen Sozialwissenschaften:Stand und Perspektiven. Bericht über einen Workshop der Deutschen Forschungsgemeinschaft