Howard Gardner : the myth of Multiple Intelligences



important in human cultures.

Are we talking about all human cultures, most, or only some of them? Gardner is not
clear on this.

Neither is there any evidence that he has surveyed a great number of human societies
in order to reach this conclusion.

There is a mystery about this „first cut’. How is it that recognizing faces fails, but
musical ability passes? Gardner does not give us any clear indication.

What he has in mind, I think, is that the ability to recognize faces is not an intellectual
area
that is culturally valued. It’s not like mathematics or music or the visual arts. If
this is so - and I give further evidence below that it is - then for something to count as
an intelligence it has to be a subdivision of the realm of the intellect. It has to be
something like a form of knowledge or understanding in the sense used by Paul Hirst
in his well-known theory of „forms of knowledge’ (1974).

If this is right, then the first thing you have to do to pick out an intelligence - as a
prerequisite - has nothing to do with empirical investigations of individuals and seeing
how their minds or their brains work. It has all to do with reflecting on the social
world - specifically that part of the social world concerned with intellectual activities
and achievements. To be an intelligence is - so far - the same as being an important
realm of understanding. MI theory is rooted not in psychological but in ethical
judgements.

I will come back to the „prerequisites’ later. As we shall see, they are of pivotal
importance.

Criteria

Once a candidate intelligence has satisfied the prerequisites, it has to meet various
criteria. These comprise (1983:62-9
):

• potential isolation of the area by brain damage

• the existence in it of idiots savants, prodigies and other exceptional individuals



More intriguing information

1. The mental map of Dutch entrepreneurs. Changes in the subjective rating of locations in the Netherlands, 1983-1993-2003
2. Artificial neural networks as models of stimulus control*
3. NEW DEVELOPMENTS IN FARM PRICE AND INCOME POLICY PROGRAMS: PART I. SITUATION AND PROBLEM
4. A dynamic approach to the tendency of industries to cluster
5. The Institutional Determinants of Bilateral Trade Patterns
6. Does South Africa Have the Potential and Capacity to Grow at 7 Per Cent?: A Labour Market Perspective
7. CREDIT SCORING, LOAN PRICING, AND FARM BUSINESS PERFORMANCE
8. Parent child interaction in Nigerian families: conversation analysis, context and culture
9. Political Rents, Promotion Incentives, and Support for a Non-Democratic Regime
10. Firm Closure, Financial Losses and the Consequences for an Entrepreneurial Restart
11. The name is absent
12. The name is absent
13. The name is absent
14. The name is absent
15. The name is absent
16. Perfect Regular Equilibrium
17. The name is absent
18. The Impact of Hosting a Major Sport Event on the South African Economy
19. The name is absent
20. The name is absent