Konjunkturprognostiker unter Panik: Kommentar



Veroffentlichungen des DIW Berlin

Friedrich Breyer, Stefan Hupfeld

Fairness of Public Pensions and Old-Age Poverty

In several OECD countries, public pay-as-you-go financed pension systems have undergone major
reforms in which future retirement benefit promises have been scaled down. A consequence of
these reforms is that especially in countries with a tight tax-benefit linkage, the retirement ben-
efit claims of low-income workers might not even exceed the minimum income guarantee which
the government provides the aged. Recently, some German politicians have criticized this likely
development because it was unjust that persons who have paid contributions over a long working
life end up with no higher benefits than people who have never worked or paid any contributions.
However, the government defended the current retirement benefit formula with the argument
that every Euro paid as contributions had exactly the same value in generating future retirement
benefits. But this logic has been questioned recently, e.g. by Breyer and Hupfeld (2007), since the
value of a contributed Euro depends on the life expectancy of the individual, which is positively
correlated with annual income. In that earlier paper, we introduced the concept of “distributive
neutrality”, which takes income-group-specific differences in life expectancy into account. The
present paper estimates the relationship between annual earnings and life expectancy of German
retirees empirically and shows how the formula that links benefits to contributions would have to
be modified to achieve distributive neutrality. We compare the new formula to the benefit formu-
las in other OECD countries and analyze a data set provided by the German Pension Insurance Of-
fice on a large cohort of pensioners to find out how the old-age poverty rate would be affected by
the proposed change of the benefit formula. Finally, we discuss other possible effects of a change
in the benefit formula, especially on the labour supply of different earnings groups.

Discussion Paper Nr. 817

September 2008

Clemens Haftendorn, Franziska Holz

Analysis of the World Market for Steam Coal Using a Complementarity
Model

With its resource availability and the prospect of climate friendly technology, coal continues to
play an important role in the global energy sector. We develop a complementarity model of the
international market for steam coal. We want to analyze the level of competition in this market
which is strategic for the importers’ security of energy supply. In a spatial equilibrium framework,
we assume the steam coal exporters to maximize their profits by choosing the optimal quantity
to sell to each importing country. We compare two possible scenarios: perfect competition and
Cournot competition. The results, especially the price levels, indicate that the Cournot model is
not realistic, suggesting that the producing countries do not exert market power. However, the
trade flows and prices observed in reality suggests that there is some form of market power with
price discrimination, possibly following a Bertrand model in a spatial setting.

Discussion Paper Nr. 818

September 2008

662


Wochenbericht des DIW Berlin Nr. 41/2008



More intriguing information

1. Word searches: on the use of verbal and non-verbal resources during classroom talk
2. EMU: some unanswered questions
3. Cultural Diversity and Human Rights: a propos of a minority educational reform
4. The name is absent
5. Feeling Good about Giving: The Benefits (and Costs) of Self-Interested Charitable Behavior
6. The name is absent
7. Giant intra-abdominal hydatid cysts with multivisceral locations
8. Restructuring of industrial economies in countries in transition: Experience of Ukraine
9. Estimating the Economic Value of Specific Characteristics Associated with Angus Bulls Sold at Auction
10. A Rare Case Of Fallopian Tube Cancer
11. fMRI Investigation of Cortical and Subcortical Networks in the Learning of Abstract and Effector-Specific Representations of Motor Sequences
12. The name is absent
13. The Folklore of Sorting Algorithms
14. An Estimated DSGE Model of the Indian Economy.
15. Surveying the welfare state: challenges, policy development and causes of resilience
16. Tax Increment Financing for Optimal Open Space Preservation: an Economic Inquiry
17. Menarchial Age of Secondary School Girls in Urban and Rural Areas of Rivers State, Nigeria
18. The name is absent
19. Endogenous Heterogeneity in Strategic Models: Symmetry-breaking via Strategic Substitutes and Nonconcavities
20. Heavy Hero or Digital Dummy: multimodal player-avatar relations in FINAL FANTASY 7