Estimating the Technology of Cognitive and Noncognitive Skill Formation



these features of the model does not prevent identification of the distribution of θ.

Nevertheless, various normalizations ensuring that the functions aj (θ, εj) are fully iden-
tified are available. For example, if each element of ε
j is normalized to be uniform (or any
other known distribution), the a
j (θ, εj) are fully identified. Other normalizations discussed
in Matzkin (2003, 2007) are also possible. Alternatively, one may assume that the a
j (θ, εj)
are separable in ε
j with zero conditional mean of εj given θ.21 We invoke these assumptions
when we identify the policy function for investments in Section 3.6.2 below.

The conditions justifying Theorems 1 and 2 are not nested within each other. Their dif-
ferent assumptions represent different trade-offs best suited for different applications. While
Theorem 1 would suffice for the empirical analysis of this paper, the general result established
in Theorem 2 will likely be quite useful as larger sample sizes become available.

Carneiro, Hansen, and Heckman (2003) present an analysis for nonseparable measurement
equations based on a separable latent index structure, but invoke strong independence and
“identification-at-infinity” assumptions. Our approach for identifying the distribution of θ
from general nonseparable measurement equations does not require these strong assumptions.
Note that it also allows the θ to determine all measurements and for the θ to be freely
correlated.

3.4 Nonparametric Identification of the Technology Function

Suppose that the shocks ηk,t are independent over time. Below, we analyze a more general
case that allows for serial dependence. Once the density of θ is known, one can identify
nonseparable technology function (2.1) for t
{1, . . . , T}; k {C, N}; and s {1, ...., S}.

Even if (θt, It, θP) were perfectly observed, one could not separately identify the distribution
of η
k,t and the function fk,s because, without further normalizations, a change in the density
of η
k,t can be undone by a change in the function fk,s.22

One solution to this problem is to assume that (2.1) is additively separable in ηk,t. An-
other way to avoid this ambiguity is to normalize η
k,t to have a uniform density on [0, 1].
Any of the normalizations suggested by Matzkin (2003, 2007) could be used. Assuming η
k,t
is uniform [0, 1] , we establish that fk,s is nonparametrically identified, by noting that, from
the knowledge of p
θ we can calculate, for any θ R,

Pr [θk,t+ι θθt, Ik,t, θp] ≡ G (⅜, Ik,t, θp) .

21Observe that Theorem 2 covers the identifiability of the outcome (Qj) functions (2.2) even if we supple-
ment the model with errors ε
j , j {1, . . . , J} that satisfy the conditions of the theorem.

22See, e.g, Matzkin (2003, 2007).

15



More intriguing information

1. IMPROVING THE UNIVERSITY'S PERFORMANCE IN PUBLIC POLICY EDUCATION
2. Tastes, castes, and culture: The influence of society on preferences
3. LIMITS OF PUBLIC POLICY EDUCATION
4. Effects of a Sport Education Intervention on Students’ Motivational Responses in Physical Education
5. Review of “From Political Economy to Economics: Method, the Social and Historical Evolution of Economic Theory”
6. A dynamic approach to the tendency of industries to cluster
7. The name is absent
8. The name is absent
9. Regional specialisation in a transition country - Hungary
10. INTERPERSONAL RELATIONS AND GROUP PROCESSES
11. The voluntary welfare associations in Germany: An overview
12. The name is absent
13. AN EXPLORATION OF THE NEED FOR AND COST OF SELECTED TRADE FACILITATION MEASURES IN ASIA AND THE PACIFIC IN THE CONTEXT OF THE WTO NEGOTIATIONS
14. Non Linear Contracting and Endogenous Buyer Power between Manufacturers and Retailers: Empirical Evidence on Food Retailing in France
15. Commitment devices, opportunity windows, and institution building in Central Asia
16. The name is absent
17. Multiple Arrhythmogenic Substrate for Tachycardia in a
18. AN EMPIRICAL INVESTIGATION OF THE PRODUCTION EFFECTS OF ADOPTING GM SEED TECHNOLOGY: THE CASE OF FARMERS IN ARGENTINA
19. The name is absent
20. Can a Robot Hear Music? Can a Robot Dance? Can a Robot Tell What it Knows or Intends to Do? Can it Feel Pride or Shame in Company?