Elicited bid functions in (a)symmetric first-price auctions



Treatment SYM


Treatment SYM (CRRA)


■ Obs □EBR □ Matched


■ Obs □EBR □ Matched


Figure 5: Distribution of bid function shapes in SYM

For each bidder, we count the number of rounds in which she/he submitted a CRRA bid
function, assuming
b = 50 (i.e., rmax = 1 ). A bid functions qualifies as a “CRRA bid
function” if it is linear with s
1 .5, s2 0 and y2 50 or concave with s1 .5, 0 s2 < s1,
b = 50, y1 b and y2 b . It appears that for 28 out of 36 subjects who ever submitted
CRRA bid functions, the average rate of submission of such bid functions is 22%. We test the
null hypothesis that the probability for a bidder to submit a CRRA bid function is equal to 0.5
against the alternative that it is smaller than 0.5. According to the Binomial test, we cannot
reject this hypothesis for only 6 subjects (at
α=.05 one-tailed). When the test is conducted
over the last 25 rounds, we cannot reject the null of CRRA bidding for one more bidder and
the modal frequency is still on Concave (i.e., about 70% of all bid functions). Therefore, as, 6
or 7 CRRA bidders out of 36 do not represent a significant rate of success according to the
Binomial test, we infer that subjects are not likely to submit CRRA bid functions. We also
tested a softer version of the CRRA model which assumes
y1 > 40 so that we allow for a non-
linearity at
b > 40 instead of the critical b = 50 . In this case the mode of the distribution of
shapes remains on Concave (57%, followed by CRRA: 31%) and we cannot reject the null of

26



More intriguing information

1. Does Competition Increase Economic Efficiency in Swedish County Councils?
2. AJAE Appendix: Willingness to Pay Versus Expected Consumption Value in Vickrey Auctions for New Experience Goods
3. Distribution of aggregate income in Portugal from 1995 to 2000 within a SAM (Social Accounting Matrix) framework. Modeling the household sector
4. Optimal Rent Extraction in Pre-Industrial England and France – Default Risk and Monitoring Costs
5. Getting the practical teaching element right: A guide for literacy, numeracy and ESOL teacher educators
6. The name is absent
7. The name is absent
8. The name is absent
9. The name is absent
10. Indirect Effects of Pesticide Regulation and the Food Quality Protection Act