Problems of operationalizing the concept of a cost-of-living index



the generalised linear utility function (r = 1) f (q) = а/p with the
corresponding general Leontief unit cost function
c (p) = b/p and the
CES function with suitable parameter restrictions
(aij = bij = O V
i = j) so that c (p) = a0 (i aipri )1/r.

A non-homothetic variant of (13) is given by ([17]Diewert (2009), p. 24)

Inc0 (p,u)


ʃo + Σ βi ln Pi + j ΣΣ ^ij ln Pi ln P^       (14)

+70ln (u) +7ilnPiln («) + 17oo (ln Ы)2
i

Obviously with vanishing 7 coefficients (14) specialises to the homothetic
cost function (13). There is not much in the ways of economic theory and
interpretation that can be said about why one functional form should be
preferred over another one.25

Ad. 2: With a given functional form the price and quantity index has to
be found which is exact for it. For example
[17]Diewert (2009) has shown
that the function

pr=2
Fot


cUM = ptBpt

c(po)    ptBpt


(15)


where p = [pι∙..p,v] coincides with Fisher’s ideal price index FJt=2 = P]^t.
Hence
Ff is exact for the “homogeneous quadratic” functional form. Corre-
spondingly the Fisher’s quantity index
Qf is equal to

r=r=2 _ ut _ f (qt)

Qot =    = fl '

uo    f (qo)

In a similar manner Diewert has shown that the Tbrnqvist price index is
exact for the translog cost function (13).26 The general form of a price index
exact for quadratic mean of order r functional form is given by

25 [28]Turvey (1999), an ingrained opponent of the COLI approach said “Writers on this
[i.e. COLI] theory express no views of which functional form is most realistic”. More
about purely formal criteria in making a choice among functional forms can be found in
[22]Lau (1986).

26He did not consider the Tornqvist quantity index. Note that the Tornqvist index does
not satisfy factor reversibility. The index function even fails the weaker product test.

15



More intriguing information

1. WP 36 - Women's Preferences or Delineated Policies? The development or part-time work in the Netherlands, Germany and the United Kingdom
2. Innovation Policy and the Economy, Volume 11
3. What Drives the Productive Efficiency of a Firm?: The Importance of Industry, Location, R&D, and Size
4. NATIONAL PERSPECTIVE
5. EU enlargement and environmental policy
6. The Role of Trait Emotional Intelligence (El) in the Workplace.
7. Demand Potential for Goat Meat in Southern States: Empirical Evidence from a Multi-State Goat Meat Consumer Survey
8. The name is absent
9. Accurate, fast and stable denoising source separation algorithms
10. A model-free approach to delta hedging