wW Σ2 pit^QiOQit , ~ w r==l
(21)
POt = = = POt = POt ∙
pLoPiO у/ QiOQit
So strictly speaking it is the indirect, rather than the direct Walsh index
which is superlative (a quadratic mean of order r = 1 index). In a similar
vein the quadratic mean of order r = 1 superlative quantity index is given
by
QO = ∑ w (Qit)
; \QiO/
r∕2^l1∕r '
∑ "C)
∙r∕2^∣ 1 r
(22)
so that forr = 1 we get QW = VOt∕PoW = Qo=1 saying that the indirect
Walsh quantity index is again a superlative index (now a quantity index).
For pairs of indices satisfying the product test there is no difference between
a direct and an indirect index. Also Vot = Q∏tP° = Pot Qot so that all four
indices are superlative (be it directly or indirectly).
Ad. 3: For a price (quantity) index P (Q) to be superlative requires
not only that P is exact for c(p) and Q for f (q) but also that f (q), and
c(p) respectively is a flexible functional form. What is meant by “flexible”.
According to Diewert a twice continuously differentiable function f (q) is
flexible if it provides a second order approximation to another function f * (q)
around the point q*, meaning that “the level and all of first and second order
partial derivatives of the two functions coincide at q*.”30 More specific one
may write (in analogy to [5]Barnett and Choi (2008), p.4)31:
f (q*) = f * (q), ( lq=q* = ) lq=q. and JfL.1 = AC ∣ (23)
Oq q q* оq q q* OqOq' q q* оqθq' q q*
Instead of “another” function f * we also find the notion of an “arbitrary
30 [16]Diewert (2008), p. 52. [17]Diewert (2009), p. 13, also stresses the requirement
that q (and q*) need to belong to the “regularity region” (of the utility function). What
is said about f (q) and q* of course also applies mutatis mutandis to the function c(p)
around the point p*. See also [3]Barnett (1983b)for different definitions of “second order
approximation” .
31For a graphical interpretation see also [29]von der Lippe (2007), p. 109. It is beyond
the scope of our paper to demonstrate exemplary what has to be done in order to show
that a specific functional form in fact is “flexible” in the definition of Diewert.
18
More intriguing information
1. Are Public Investment Efficient in Creating Capital Stocks in Developing Countries?2. Evidence-Based Professional Development of Science Teachers in Two Countries
3. Skills, Partnerships and Tenancy in Sri Lankan Rice Farms
4. The name is absent
5. Concerns for Equity and the Optimal Co-Payments for Publicly Provided Health Care
6. Dendritic Inhibition Enhances Neural Coding Properties
7. EU Preferential Partners in Search of New Policy Strategies for Agriculture: The Case of Citrus Sector in Trinidad and Tobago
8. The value-added of primary schools: what is it really measuring?
9. Innovation Policy and the Economy, Volume 11
10. Comparative study of hatching rates of African catfish (Clarias gariepinus Burchell 1822) eggs on different substrates