Dual Track Reforms: With and Without Losers



the second period is given by


S0-1 (Q) =


S -1 ( Q ) + δPe

1 + δ


and the corresponding first period demand is given by

D0-1(Q) =


D-1( Q ) + δPe

1 + δ


5 The Dynamic Welfare Implications of Dual Track
Reform

We are now ready to evaluate whether, from a dynamic perspective, anticipated dual track
liberalization is efficiency enhancing and Pareto improving as compared to the status quo.
As it turns out, the answer to this question depends on whether the original government
policy involves an intervention only in one or in multiple dimensions. Instead of providing
an exhaustive analysis of the various possible types of government intervention, we illus-
trate our arguments by means of three examples. First we consider a price setting policy,
and then a quantity restriction accompanied by price setting with and without involuntary
participation/exclusion.
6

5.1 Single-Dimension Intervention: Price Setting

Suppose the government fixes the price at P in the first period, and assume that this policy
results in excessive demand (that is, the supply is binding). In this case, the second period
market price
P e must be higher than P , as Figure 2 illustrates. In the first period, if
agents do not anticipate future policy changes, the quantity exchanged will be
Q1, so that
S-1 (Q1) = P. When a dual track liberalization is instead expected, sellers have an incentive
to withhold their sales in the first period, in order to avoid being locked into a contract fixing
the low price
P . At the same time, buyers have an additional incentive to transact in the first
period so as to lock up the low price
P. This implies that the first period excessive demand
persists under the anticipated dual track liberalization. Let
Q1d be the equilibrium quantity
transacted in the first period under the anticipated dual track liberalization. Following

6For a more complete analysis, see Che and Facchini (2004).



More intriguing information

1. Impacts of Tourism and Fiscal Expenditure on Remote Islands in Japan: A Panel Data Analysis
2. Impact of Ethanol Production on U.S. and Regional Gasoline Prices and On the Profitability of U.S. Oil Refinery Industry
3. What should educational research do, and how should it do it? A response to “Will a clinical approach make educational research more relevant to practice” by Jacquelien Bulterman-Bos
4. Should informal sector be subsidised?
5. The purpose of this paper is to report on the 2008 inaugural Equal Opportunities Conference held at the University of East Anglia, Norwich
6. Learning and Endogenous Business Cycles in a Standard Growth Model
7. Short Term Memory May Be the Depletion of the Readily Releasable Pool of Presynaptic Neurotransmitter Vesicles
8. AN EMPIRICAL INVESTIGATION OF THE PRODUCTION EFFECTS OF ADOPTING GM SEED TECHNOLOGY: THE CASE OF FARMERS IN ARGENTINA
9. Climate Policy under Sustainable Discounted Utilitarianism
10. Determinants of Household Health Expenditure: Case of Urban Orissa