On the Desirability of Taxing Charitable Contributions



social marginal benefit of the transfer (T) and μ1 - μ2 > 0 [see equation (17)] is the
social marginal benefit of the public good (
g) completes the interpretation of equation
(18). Naturally, equation (18) reduces to:

(19)  dL

s


0t* T* *,. =μ2 z [1 - F(ι^)] 0.

As explained above, a unit tax on contributions shifts resources at the amount of

z [1 - F(ι^)] from the public good provision (g) to the uniform transfer (T). The net
marginal social benefit of this shift is indeed
μ2 z [1 - F(ι^)], because μ2 is the
difference between the marginal social benefit of the uniform transfer (
μ1 ) and the
public good (
μ1 - μ2). Note that the marginal social benefit of increasing g cannot
exceed that of increasing
T, because g is subject also to an additional constraint
according to which it cannot fall short of the total amount of contributions. Thus, we
establish:

Proposition 2: When contributions are purely driven by status seeking (β = 1), the
optimal tax on contributions is non-negative.

Note that when the constraint in equation (11), which states that the
government may not confiscate contributions and direct them towards its general
budget [equation (10)], is binding, we may plausibly assume that the corresponding
Lagrange multiplier (μ2) is strictly positive. In this case, it is optimal to levy a
positive tax on contributions. Naturally, this will be the case when the demand for the
public good is sufficiently small (that is, when
α is sufficiently small).

In contrast, when the demand for the public good is high enough (that is, when
α is large enough), the constraint in equation (11) will not be binding. Hence, μ2 = 0,
and it becomes optimal to set
s=0. That is, it is not optimal for the government to

19



More intriguing information

1. Cancer-related electronic support groups as navigation-aids: Overcoming geographic barriers
2. Higher education funding reforms in England: the distributional effects and the shifting balance of costs
3. Chebyshev polynomial approximation to approximate partial differential equations
4. Graphical Data Representation in Bankruptcy Analysis
5. Contribution of Economics to Design of Sustainable Cattle Breeding Programs in Eastern Africa: A Choice Experiment Approach
6. Credit Markets and the Propagation of Monetary Policy Shocks
7. The name is absent
8. LOCAL CONTROL AND IMPROVEMENT OF COMMUNITY SERVICE
9. Regional specialisation in a transition country - Hungary
10. The name is absent