An alternative way to model merit good arguments



The interpretation of (14) is as follows. Suppose the agent has (x, y) avail-
able. Then in order to reach a utility level U, she believes F
(x, y,u) units of the
numéraire are required, while the government, convinced of the merit properties of
the third commodity, believes F
g(x,y,u) units are sufficient. What (13) then tells
is that the slope of the government’s indifference curve through
(Fg(x, y, U), x, y)
differs from the slope of the consumer’s indifference curve through (F(x, y, U), x, y)
with a factor μ(y).

To this TWP function corresponds a utility function ug (), defined as

ug (Fg(x, y, ν),x,y,ν) ν (all ν).                     (15)

It is easy to show that

ug (z, x, y)


= u z+ + У* μ(χ)dχ,x,y^


(16)


(see appendix). A sufficient condition for ug() to be strongly quasi-concave is
that μ
0() 0.

The two MRS expressions necessary to compute the optimal tax rates are
therefore

ug

J (z,x,y)

u1

g
u3

—(z,χ,y)
u1


u2        y

= (z+ I μ(χ)dχ,χ,y)

U1      yya

U3      yV

=(z +/ μ(X),χ,y)+ μ(y).

uι   ⅛


(17a)

(17b)


Again, the reason (17b) is not exactly μ(y) is that the evaluation here is at the
same bundle, not at the same utility level as in (13). A sufficient condition for
single crossing of indifference curves (in the sense that sig n
(MRSygz - MRSyz)=
sign(μ(y')')} is that the (de)merit good is a normal good (in the sense that ∂∂Z ( u3 ) >
0).

Inserting (17) in (6) and using a Taylor expansion of ui(z + J^ μ(χ)dχ,x,y)
around u- (z,x,y) gives

(∂ u2 (z,x,y) yy

tχ  '  -Ç u1 dZ , J y9μ(χ)dχ                    (18a)

∂∂ u3 (z,x,y)

ty ` - u1 dz— J y μ(x)dx - μ(y)           (18b)

The round bracket terms on the rhs denotes the uncompensated effect of
a marginal increase in z on the demand price for each of the non-
numéraire
commodities . The signs of these effects are related to the normality of these



More intriguing information

1. Higher education funding reforms in England: the distributional effects and the shifting balance of costs
2. Behavioural Characteristics and Financial Distress
3. The name is absent
4. Expectation Formation and Endogenous Fluctuations in Aggregate Demand
5. Benefits of travel time savings for freight transportation : beyond the costs
6. MICROWORLDS BASED ON LINEAR EQUATION SYSTEMS: A NEW APPROACH TO COMPLEX PROBLEM SOLVING AND EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS
7. The name is absent
8. The name is absent
9. The Role of Immigration in Sustaining the Social Security System: A Political Economy Approach
10. Mean Variance Optimization of Non-Linear Systems and Worst-case Analysis